Children and Electronic Media -- Myth Busters

| 8 Comments

There are a lot of myths about how children use electronic media, highlighted in our recent volume, Children and Electronic Media. A longer version of this “Myth Busters” piece and other related highlights are posted on our website. 

MYTH: Television is being displaced by newer forms of media.
REALITY: Despite all the new technologies, children still spend a lot of time in front of the television. Rather than newer technologies replacing television, children simply add these other media on to the time they spend watching TV.
 
MYTH: Children from highly educated families use electronic media the least, while children in less educated families use it the most.  
REALITY: Youth whose parents had completed college reported the most media exposure, while those whose parents had completed no more than high school reported less but were not far behind. The group with the least media exposure was children whose parents had some college education.
 
MYTH: Marketing to children can never have positive outcomes.
REALITY: While advertising is often used to steer children and youth toward unhealthy behaviors, marketing can also be used effectively to promote positive healthy choices such as not smoking or using illicit drugs, reducing obesity, and delaying sexual activity – some of which are highlighted our policy brief, “Using Media to Promote Adolescent Wellbeing,” and in an article by Doug Evans on social marketing campaigns.
 
MYTH: Video games have no educational value.
REALITY: Violent video games can promote aggressive (though not necessarily criminal) behavior, but many other types of video games promote positive outcomes. Studies have found, for instance, that playing select video games can enhance visual awareness, including greater capacity to pay attention, quicker attention deployment, and faster processing.  
 
MYTH: Adolescents use online communication primarily to communicate with strangers.
REALITY: Teens mostly use the Internet to communicate with friends and maintain already existing relationships. However, even teens who only seek to communicate with friends may do so in inappropriate ways that leave them vulnerable to harassment. Moreover, some contact with strangers – seeking out health information, for example -- is not necessarily negative.  
 
MYTH: Television is appropriate for all ages, so long as it is educational.
REALITY: Watching television is unlikely to be beneficial for infants and toddlers and could actually be harmful. Research shows that viewing educational television can have positive effects for preschoolers and older children, but there is no research supporting the same outcomes for children ages two and under.  
 
MYTH: Ratings systems are reliable ways to know the content and appropriateness of a movie, television, or video game program.
REALITY: Ratings are rarely well understood by the general public. They are inconsistent from media to media, parents are often not fully aware of the information and criteria used in each rating system, and sometimes parents are even unaware that the ratings exist.    Even among parents who report using industry-provided ratings and advisories, most do not find them to be “very useful.”
 
MYTH: Electronic media are keeping kids from reading.
REALITY: It does not seem that time with media greatly displaces reading or doing homework, largely because American youth spend so little time doing either.
 
For more information, see Children and Electronic Media, eds. Jeanne Brooks-Gunn and Elisabeth Donahue, Spring 2008 and our 10-paper series of short  "Highlights" for articles on all the topics presented above.   

8 Comments

This is an interesting subject that concerns me greatly. What I hear is that media could have a positive effect on our kids, but typically it does not. I think we need to start by educating parents on the subject and teach them how to make choices that will actually benefit their children.

I am not sure I agree that media typically does not have have a positive impact. It truly depends on the content. Probably more significantly, electronic media is here to stay -- so as parents, community members, teachers, we have to ensure that the content is something that can have a positive impact rather than trying to make media go away. Just imagine, without the internet you and I wouldn't be able to even debate this point!

This is a very interesting post. I actually wrote a short thesis for this in high school. My stance is the media, propaganda, and incentive programs the big companies put into affect to control the market. So many people have there eyes wide shut and can't even step back to notice the bigger picture. Unfortunately there is no stopping it as the younger generations are more brainwashed than the older generations. This trend can also be tracked through the years of our civilizations development.

I totally agree with you on video games.... it makes you think quicker and increases your reaction times. Most older adults can not even follow the action in most video games as their minds can not process informtion that quickly.

I think this is a great and fair post. Video games or gaming systems are not always negative, no matter how often the skeptics speak aloud.

I think we need to start by educating parents on the subject and teach them how to make choices that will actually benefit their children.

Multiple URLS on this page to the cited documents are broken. I'd like to see study "Children and Electronic Media"

@ games -- but that isn't necessarily a good thing. I played lots of videogames growing up and I can tell you that I wished my parents had forced me outside more.

Archives

Recent Comments

  • mrmattbubbly: @ games -- but that isn't necessarily a good thing.…
    read more
  • Tim O'Shaughnessy: Multiple URLS on this page to the cited documents are…
    read more
  • Sharilewis: I think we need to start by educating parents on…
    read more
  • Gary: I think this is a great and fair post. Video…
    read more
  • games: I totally agree with you on video games.... it makes…
    read more
  • sales incentives: This is a very interesting post. I actually wrote a…
    read more
  • Elisabeth Donahue: I am not sure I agree that media typically does…
    read more
  • Biggi: This is an interesting subject that concerns me greatly. What…
    read more