Men’s Basketball — Princeton vs. Georgetown, 1989: Who does not like a David versus Goliath matchup?

On March 17, 1989, in the open­ing round of the NCAA men’s bas­ket­ball tour­na­ment, Prince­ton Uni­ver­sity, seeded #16, faced national pow­er­house George­town Uni­ver­sity, seeded #1 in the East Region. It was a clas­sic David ver­sus Goliath matchup. Since the tour­na­ment was expanded to 64 teams in 1985, a #16 seed has never defeated a #1 seed. There have been some close calls, but none closer than Georgetown’s nar­row one point vic­tory over Princeton.

The video below fea­tures four seg­ments from the game. At the begin­ning of the broad­cast (0.04), Dick Vitale, noted col­lege bas­ket­ball com­men­ta­tor and ana­lyst, and John Saun­ders dis­cuss the game. Vitale promises to don a Prince­ton cheer­leader out­fit if Prince­ton can beat George­town. He, like so many oth­ers, gave the Tigers lit­tle chance against the big­ger, faster, and stronger Hoyas. Princeton took the floor as twenty-three point underdogs.

The start­ing line ups are pre­sented in the sec­ond seg­ment (0:28), and view­ers can watch the first six min­utes of the game (from 3:58), and see the final three min­utes of play (from 12:03), includ­ing Vitale’s reac­tion to Princeton’s per­for­mance and near victory.
George­town, under head coach John Thomp­son, entered the tour­na­ment ranked #2 in the coun­try and had recently won the Big East Con­fer­ence title. They had a 26–4 pre-tournament record, and the team was loaded with tal­ent, includ­ing fresh­man star and future NBA player Alonzo Mourn­ing and senior cap­tain Charles Smith, the Big East Player of the Year. Many pre­dicted them to win the tournament.

Callill1.jpgPrince­ton, led by their famously col­or­ful coach Pete Car­ril (left), was 19–8 over­all, and as Ivy League cham­pi­ons had earned an auto­matic bid to the national tournament. They were a young team, with only one junior, Matt Lapin, and one senior, Ivy League Player of the Year and cap­tain Bob Scra­bis, on the roster. But, this was also a Prince­ton team that led the nation in defense, allow­ing only 53 points per game.

How could Prince­ton stay with George­town and keep the game close? The “Prince­ton Offense,” the hall­mark of Carril’s coach­ing style, slowed down the Hoyas and forced an entirely dif­fer­ent style of play. The “Prince­ton Offense” spread the floor, uti­liz­ing a three guard set, and made the con­test a half court game. Clock man­age­ment and patience were key.
In those days the shot clock was 45 sec­onds, and it was quite typ­i­cal for Prince­ton to run the clock down for 30 sec­onds before they even began their offen­sive set. With con­stant ball move­ment and pass­ing, the guards looked for play­ers mov­ing toward the bas­ket, espe­cially by back door cuts, which led to easy lay ups.
This style of play stymied George­town through­out the first half, and Princeton’s con­fi­dence seemed to grow with each basket. They picked up rebounds, scram­bled for loose balls, lim­ited turnovers, and gen­er­ally frus­trated the Hoyas. At half time, Prince­ton led 29–21, and there was a notice­able buzz of excite­ment in the arena.

Prince­ton played solid defense through­out the game, but what changed for them in the sec­ond half was their inabil­ity to get rebounds. In the first half they out-rebounded George­town, but in the sec­ond half the Tigers strug­gled on the boards. At one point, George­town had 17 rebounds to Princeton’s one.

The game see­sawed for much of the sec­ond half, with Prince­ton keep­ing it close. With 1:38 remain­ing and the game tied, the crowd, now solidly behind the Tigers, sensed an upset in the making. With 0:23 sec­onds to go, Scra­bis fouled Mourn­ing, send­ing him to the line for a cru­cial one-and-one. The fresh­man, fac­ing enor­mous pres­sure, made the first shot but missed the second. Scrabis pulled down the rebound and with 0:18 sec­onds, Prince­ton brought the ball down court, trail­ing by only one point, 49–50.
Fol­low­ing a time out, Prince­ton inbounded the ball at mid-court. Scra­bis’ shot was blocked by Mourn­ing. After a scram­ble for the ball and with one sec­ond remain­ing, Prince­ton, still down by only one point, inbounded the ball from the side­line. Kit Mueller’s shot at the buzzer missed, and George­town escaped by the nar­row­est of mar­gins, 50–49.
VitalePrinceton.jpgBack in the stu­dio Vitale appeared in a Prince­ton sweat­shirt and all the talk in the bas­ket­ball world for a while was of the near upset. Despite the loss, the result of the game was a proud moment for Prince­ton bas­ket­ball, as it demon­strated that it could play with the best of them.

–Kris­ten Turner

The VHS tape cap­tur­ing this footage is part of the Uni­ver­sity Archives’ His­tor­i­cal Audio­vi­sual Col­lec­tion (item no. 1497). Images are taken from this tape. Addi­tional com­men­tary may be found in the Daily Prince­ton of March 20, 1989.

 

You must log in to post a comment.